action string | change_trigger string | config string | control_id string | decision_job string | evidence_type list | field_origin string | limitations list | name string | owner_role string | review_status string | risk string | rollback string | snapshot_at timestamp[s] | source_commit_sha string | source_data_hash string | source_native_id null | source_payload_json string | source_url string | status string | system_boundary string | verification string | verified_at null |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Define included component classes, environments and discovery methods; enumerate inaccessible or unsupported components. | The system boundary or discovery method changes. | aibom | AIBOM-SCOPE | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Declared scope and exclusion list",
"Discovery coverage check"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Inventory scope and blind spots | AI platform owner | NOT_REVIEWED | An inventory is treated as complete although the scanner cannot observe some components. | Pause promotion for unresolved critical inventory gaps; restore the last understood boundary without claiming scanner completeness. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Compare one known component of each in-scope class against the inventory and record omissions. | null |
Record stable component identifiers, release versions and available content digests; mark unavailable identities explicitly. | A model, package, prompt, data snapshot or build changes. | aibom | AIBOM-IDENTITY | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Version and digest manifest",
"Inventory diff"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Immutable component identity | Release engineering owner | NOT_REVIEWED | A mutable label hides a component change. | Block the unidentified component and restore a known compatible identity after verifying that it remains supported and authorized. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Change a fixture version or digest and confirm the inventory diff exposes it. | null |
Record origin, producer, acquisition path and referenced provenance separately from verification status. | Origin, producer, acquisition path or provenance policy changes. | aibom | AIBOM-PROVENANCE | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Origin references",
"Provenance verification record"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Traceable provenance | Supply-chain security owner | NOT_REVIEWED | A component cannot be linked to its asserted origin. | Quarantine the component if required provenance cannot be verified; retain the evidence used for the decision. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Trace a selected component to the retained origin record; mark unverifiable assertions as unknown. | null |
Record the applicable license or terms reference, proposed use, open questions and the human decision owner. | License, terms, intended use, data access or distribution changes. | aibom | AIBOM-RIGHTS | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Version-specific terms reference",
"Named rights and access decision"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Permitted use and data access | Rights reviewer with the data owner | NOT_REVIEWED | A release depends on a component or dataset whose allowed use is unresolved. | Block the affected use or distribution and select a reviewed permitted substitute; preserve the rights decision history. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Inspect the exact version and use decision; do not treat a scanner license label as approval. | null |
When attestations are required, verify the subject digest, signature identity and expected producer policy before accepting the claim. | Subject digest, signer trust, producer policy or verification tooling changes. | aibom | AIBOM-ATTESTATION | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Attestation and subject digest",
"Trust-policy version",
"Positive and negative verification records"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Attestation subject and trust verification | Supply-chain security owner | NOT_REVIEWED | A valid-looking attestation is accepted for the wrong artifact or producer. | Reject the untrusted attestation and block the component; re-admit only after verification against a reviewed policy. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Reject fixtures with a changed subject digest, untrusted signer or unexpected producer; retain the verification outcome. | null |
Compare the candidate inventory with the approved baseline and route material changes to named component owners. | Any in-scope inventory item or its permissions change. | aibom | AIBOM-DIFF | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Baseline and candidate inventories",
"Material diff and decision log"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Material inventory change review | Release engineering owner | NOT_REVIEWED | A dependency change reaches production without an owned review. | Hold promotion and restore a compatible reviewed inventory after checking migrations and external effects. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Introduce a new component and a permission change in a fixture; confirm both appear in the review record. | null |
Bind the inventory to an enforceable admission decision and a current revocation process. | Admission policy, trust status, exposure or revocation information changes. | aibom | AIBOM-ADMISSION | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Admission policy and decisions",
"Revocation exercise"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Dependency admission and revocation | Platform security owner | NOT_REVIEWED | A revoked or disallowed dependency remains available at runtime. | Revoke the affected capability and use a reviewed supported fallback; deployment rollback must not reintroduce revoked components. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Attempt admission of a permitted and a revoked fixture; confirm both decisions are attributable. | null |
Assign a responsible maintainer and accountable release owner; define review triggers and retain change history. | Team ownership, release process, component lifecycle or evidence location changes. | aibom | AIBOM-OWNERSHIP | RELEASE_EVIDENCE | [
"Owner assignment",
"Review schedule and trigger record",
"Change history"
] | Original engineering proposal; the source compares tools and does not contain these controls. | [
"Engineering draft; independent human review is pending.",
"A listed artifact or suggested role does not establish operating effectiveness or an actual assignment.",
"New normalized fields require canonical upstream adoption before public release."
] | Inventory ownership and maintenance | System owner | NOT_REVIEWED | Inventory evidence becomes stale without an accountable maintainer. | Pause unowned changes and assign an accountable replacement before reopening promotion. | 2026-09-17T06:17:24 | 462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7 | sha256:13c2f516b1aaa41bea93a799cc4999d38490e365faa1c8a31eeb4731593fd49a | null | null | https://github.com/PharosProduction/aibom-tools-compared/blob/462388081577ba7155ace498cb7555304a01fbb7/data/tools.json | DRAFT | The selected release and its model, prompt, data, tool and runtime dependency inventory. | Simulate an ownership transfer and verify that review and escalation routes remain reachable. | null |
Control Evidence Dataset v0.1
Public v0.1 candidate · reviewed and approved for publication by Dmytro Nasyrov on September 17, 2026.
This public candidate contains 55 draft control records for release-evidence preparation. Each record connects an engineering action to requested evidence, a suggested owner, a change trigger and recovery guidance. The companion Evidence Pack collects version-specific references and exposes missing records.
Pharos Production's published AI agent security control mapping method addresses the gap between a control statement and an inspectable implementation check. This candidate combines that method with drift and governance catalogs, while separating new engineering proposals from source facts.
Contents
| Config | Draft rows | Content and origin |
|---|---|---|
security |
24 | Source implementation checks and evidence types. Proposed risk, boundary, change-trigger and rollback mappings. |
aibom |
8 | New proposed inventory, provenance, rights, attestation, admission and ownership controls. The upstream five-product comparison is retained as context, not relabeled as controls. |
drift |
11 | Source metric definitions, responses and rollback guidance. Proposed evidence and ownership mappings. |
governance |
12 | Source purposes, requested records and suggested roles. Proposed risk, change-trigger and recovery fields. |
All partitions use the draft split. Every row has review_status=NOT_REVIEWED, status=DRAFT and verified_at=null. These frozen per-record fields describe the original preparation snapshot. The subsequent owner review and publication authorization are recorded in publication-approval.json; they do not represent operational control validation.
How to use the records
The consumer selects applicable controls and supplies a system boundary, release version, accountable person, evidence references and recovery record. Missing, unreviewed, stale or version-mismatched references remain visible as gaps. A complete list of user-entered references still does not establish adequacy or operating effectiveness. The catalog never supplies an actual owner assignment or a human acceptance decision.
Control rows expose control_id, risk, system_boundary, action, verification, evidence_type, owner_role, change_trigger, rollback and lineage fields. field_origin distinguishes copied source fields from proposed mappings. source_payload_json retains the native source record. It is null for newly authored AIBOM controls.
The current schema.json is candidate schema 2.0.0-candidate.1. The earlier public-release contract is preserved byte-for-byte as release-schema-v1.json. Candidate states are a deliberate schema change. They do not satisfy the earlier REVIEWED gate. A consumer of the old schema must opt into the candidate contract explicitly.
Reproducibility and provenance
source-snapshot.json retains the exact native file contents, source commits and file hashes. source-manifest.json indexes them. source-proposals.json records new AI-assisted engineering suggestions separately. Those suggestions have not been adopted into canonical upstream sources. The eight AIBOM controls are authored preparation material, not observed results.
To check a downloaded repository with Python's standard library, run:
python3 exporter.py --verify-dataset .
The check rebuilds every JSONL partition and data.json in memory, compares the exported bytes and verifies the retained source-file hashes. It makes no network call. The Space locks the dataset to an exact Hugging Face commit and checks the bundled data.json SHA-256 before evaluation.
Boundaries and review
Drift thresholds in the retained native records are illustrative settings, not validated limits. Governance controls are planning aids, not a compliance determination. Recovery guidance must be checked against migrations, revoked data and external effects. Restoring a deployment does not undo an external action.
No client records, production telemetry or credentials are included. Examples in the Space are explicitly fictional. AI assistance prepared normalized fields, proposals and packaging. Automated checks cannot supply independent human review, rights approval or actual operational evidence. Dmytro Nasyrov subsequently confirmed that he had checked the package and authorized this public candidate. This owner attestation does not establish independent review, operational effectiveness or canonical adoption of proposals.
Rights and corrections
LICENSE-NOTICE.md preserves source-specific MIT and CC BY 4.0 declarations and attribution. Linked third-party works retain their owners' terms. No new blanket license or human rights-approval signature is asserted for the combined candidate.
Correct source facts in the relevant canonical repository, then regenerate the snapshot. Review new proposals in source-proposals.json before adopting them upstream. Report packaging defects with a record ID, exact dataset revision and file hash, without private evidence payloads. See CHANGELOG.md for this candidate's changes.
- Downloads last month
- 43